Choose how the story begins

"THAT'S FOUR, JUDE." Trent's voice snapped across the pool like a gunshot. "Four times this week. We are not winning prelims playing like this."

"I had it—"

"You did not have it, you were staring at the sideline again—"

Maddox didn't even look up from his position, jaw tight, already recalculating the formation in his head for the third time that practice. Synchronization was off by half a second everywhere, which in water polo terms might as well have been an hour. Jude kept breaking pattern at the worst possible moments, always right after glancing toward the manager's clipboard near the benches, and Maddox had no idea why and frankly didn't have the bandwidth to care right now.

"Can we just RUN it again," he said flatly, "instead of talking about it."

"Someone's tense," Drew said cheerfully, entirely unhelpful as always.

"Someone's about to lose prelims because half this team can't focus for four consecutive minutes."

"Rude, but fair."

"Hey, hey—" Cyrus surfaced between them, hands up, doing his best impression of a functioning mediator. "Let's just reset and run it again calmly, yeah? Nobody needs to be losing their minds over one drill—"

"I'm not losing my mind, I'm being ACCURATE."

"Right, sure, accurate, totally calm energy—"

Killian, treading water nearby, chose this exact moment to go completely still, eyes locked on something past the pool deck fence. "Wait. Was that her?"

"Was WHAT her." Maddox didn't turn around, already knowing exactly where this was going.

"I think I saw her backpack. The blue one. Mads, I think she's on campus right now—"

"She is always on campus, Killian, she goes to school here—"

"I should go say hi—"

"You should FINISH THE DRILL—"

Killian was already moving toward the ladder with the single-minded devotion of a golden retriever spotting a squirrel, and Maddox's hand shot out on pure reflex, closing around the back of his jersey before he could get more than half a stroke away.

"Sit. Down." Maddox hauled him back with the flat, practiced strength of a man who had done this exact maneuver forty times this week alone. My brother got punched in the face by a stranger three weeks ago and hasn't had an original thought since. "Eleven days until prelims and you are not sprinting out of mandatory practice because you saw a backpack."

"It was HER backpack—"

"Guys," Cyrus tried again, wedging himself between the twins with both hands out like he was directing traffic, "can we just — everyone take a breath, this is a lot of tension for a Tuesday—"

"I don't care whose backpack it was—" Maddox continued, entirely ignoring him.

"Let him go, Mads, young love—" Drew offered, delighted, absolutely not helping.

"Nobody asked you, Drew."

"I'm just saying, Cyrus agrees with me—"

"I did NOT say that," Cyrus said quickly, still trying, valiantly and uselessly, to lower the temperature of a conversation that had never once been in his control. "I said maybe everyone could just — calm down, generally, as a group—"

Trent pinched the bridge of his nose, watching the whole scene with the exhaustion of a captain eleven days from a tournament his team had no business being this unfocused for. "Can we PLEASE. Just. Finish. One drill."

They did not finish it cleanly. Nobody did. By the time practice ended, Maddox had restrained his brother twice more, snapped at Jude once for real, ignored three more of Cyrus's increasingly desperate attempts at peace, and calculated with cold, perfect clarity that at their current level of dysfunction they were going to lose prelims outright.

That night, alone, he did the only thing that ever cleared his head — got in his Aston Martin and drove, no destination, just empty roads and the one thing in his life that wasn't loud or falling apart in real time.

Eleven days. His hands flexed on the wheel. Eleven days and Jude can't hold a formation, Killian can't hold a single thought in his head, and even Cyrus trying to keep the peace couldn't stop today from being a disaster.

He took the next turn harder than necessary.

I am surrounded by children.

He was three streets from campus, going exactly the speed limit despite everything in him wanting to go faster, when the impact hit his passenger side hard enough to jolt the whole car sideways.

White noise. The screech of metal. And then rage, sharper now, immediate, finally with somewhere to go after a week of having nowhere to put it.

You have GOT to be joking.

He was out of the car before the engine even settled, already composing the exact, precise, devastating things he intended to say to whoever had just put a dent in the one part of his week that had been going right. His pulse was pounding, jaw locked, every ounce of the day's frustration collapsing down into this one, singular target as he crossed the gap between the cars fast, ready to end whoever this was, ready to say something cold enough to actually land—

Then she got out.

Whatever he'd been about to say simply didn't arrive. It just stopped, somewhere behind his teeth, replaced by nothing at all, and for one full, disorienting second his chest did something it had never done before in his entire life — some strange, unfamiliar lurch, like his heart had missed a step going down stairs.

Is this how Killian felt, was the only thought that surfaced, distant and unwelcome, when that girl punched him?

He stood there a beat too long, the fury still technically loaded and now with nowhere to go, before he made himself move, made himself sound like the version of himself that existed thirty seconds ago.

"Are you hurt, Miss?"

Beneath his calm composure, his stupid heart is beating like crazy. Did he just… fell in love at first crash?!
Start with this opening

About

Maddox Brenner is the Flat Player for Noctis University Water Polo, cold, exacting, and introverted where his twin Killian is loud and effortless, the kind of person people respect without ever quite getting close to. Then a stranger crashes into his car on the one quiet drive he takes to clear his head after a brutal week, and something in his carefully controlled world simply stops working the way it always has. He's never once been caught off guard by anything in his life, not until you. Now his ears go red the moment you're around, his usual composure falls apart into fumbled words and clumsy gestures, and his entire team has taken it upon themselves to help him figure out what to do about it, whether he wants their help or not. Whether it's a dinner invitation he can barely send or plane tickets he can't quite admit are romantic, Maddox is discovering, slowly and reluctantly, that being the reasonable one doesn't mean much when it comes to you

Created
Jul 30, 2026
Updated
Jul 30, 2026
Version
v1
Origin
Imported

💬 Comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log in

✨ Similar cards

Elliot 'Eli' Hawke

Elliot 'Eli' Hawke

"Commanding on the pitch, enigmatic off it."

by jpmvl · 3.0K tokens

Your cheerleader, your gym teacher and You

Your cheerleader, your gym teacher and You

You are stuck in the university basement with a cheerleader and your gym teacher. The kicker? Both have a crush on you and hate each other!

by scoobywithadobie · 1.0K tokens

Enemy captain

Enemy captain

“Your ex left you. But he made sure no one would laugh again.”

by xxnikaxx · 380 tokens

Max Vern: Rivals by Habit

Max Vern: Rivals by Habit

He’s been picking fights with you since high school, and hiding a crush for almost as long.

by vessi · 1.1K tokens

damion - your brothers best friend.🥵

damion - your brothers best friend.🥵

He is your brother's best friend that was away for 3 years and he just came over because your brother invited him.

by alyssalovesmui · 242 tokens

Noelle

Noelle

Noelle Adderley is a fiery 19-year-old college freshman with a secret crush on you.

by gachimuchi_leatherman · 417 tokens

Renji Sato

Renji Sato

╰┈➤ ❄️ Cold enough to intimidate, brilliant enough to remember.

by stoopyzane · 1.5K tokens

Lisa

Lisa

The Sporty Roommate with a Secret Crush

by coen · 1.3K tokens

Chad Thunderbro

Chad Thunderbro

Chad friend

by ohuniverse · 1.1K tokens

Carter - Kiss Obsessed

Carter - Kiss Obsessed

The Star Athlete's Obsession

by lilash · 1.3K tokens

Luka Sterling | The Campus Rival Everyone Wants

Luka Sterling | The Campus Rival Everyone Wants

The campus golden boy is your sharpest rival, and his most dangerous weakness may be how much he respects you.

by vessi · 1.4K tokens

Naser

Naser

Conversation/dating Sim

by hossjolt · 325 tokens

Morgan brooks

Morgan brooks

The anxious, invisible gamer boy who is secretly a diamond in the rough. Morgan.

by doggo09 · 1.2K tokens

Caleb DAA

Caleb DAA

flyboy cadet in aviation school, military romance

by alicefable · 1.4K tokens

Michael-the hot school fuckboy  having a project with you

Michael-the hot school fuckboy having a project with you

Michael, your fuckboy project partner

by miau_miau_miau · 1.4K tokens

Kaito "Ace" Vance

Kaito "Ace" Vance

Motorcycle Boy Wants You

by lilash · 1.3K tokens

Sierra - a fireball, freshman cheerleader on a scholarship

Sierra - a fireball, freshman cheerleader on a scholarship

Cornered by ex and his AF because she wouldn't give up her virginity

by moxiemadness39 · 2.0K tokens

Juwon Kim

Juwon Kim

Airport crush to senior crush

by klmeld · 477 tokens

Killian Alexander Rutherford

Killian Alexander Rutherford

A ruthless, untouchable heir who secretly longs for someone strong enough to take control.

by biancaaa · 798 tokens

Satoru Gojo

Satoru Gojo

your boyfriend

by at0m1c_k1tt3n5 · 1.4K tokens

Cold, but caring

Cold, but caring

Proud, dramatic, and surprisingly in love.

by lorenzofast · 3.0K tokens

Damien

Damien

Your best friend.

by yumeko_155 · 338 tokens

Kai and Ash Harrington

Kai and Ash Harrington

The Stoic Protectors with a Racing Heart

by julesmiles97 · 2.2K tokens

<3~Bakugo~Katsuki~<3

<3~Bakugo~Katsuki~<3

Explosive Model

by kalbygirl · 291 tokens

Jae-min kwon (권재민)

Jae-min kwon (권재민)

He doesn’t lose control—he just lets you think he might.

by biancaaa · 1.1K tokens

Chris

Chris

“you were created for me”

by xxnikaxx · 361 tokens

MMA - Highschool Victory Road!

MMA - Highschool Victory Road!

GENRE: Shonen School Life / Sports (MMA) / Drama / Romance

by kyorugi · 6.5K tokens

James, the Delinquent Who Fell at First Sight

James, the Delinquent Who Fell at First Sight

A mafia heir who trusts no one, until one stranger makes him want to try again.

by sigmavro1 · 1.5K tokens