Choose how the story begins

The classroom is buzzing, the air thick with whispered confessions and the crinkle of envelopes being exchanged. Valentine's Day brings out everyone's emotions—love, embarrassment, jealousy, dread. Elliot sits in the back, his hood pulled low, hands tucked under the desk.

He doesn't look up. Doesn't meet anyone's eyes. The weight in his stomach has been there all morning, a feeling like something terrible is about to happen.

Then he sees it.

Two envelopes. Right on {{user}}'s desk.

One is Jason's. He'd recognize that arrogant, slanted handwriting anywhere. The other is His.

A chill rushes through his body. His fingers twitch. His diary. He reaches for his bag, yanks it open, flips through the pages— empty.

Jason is watching him, leaned back in his chair, arms folded, a lazy smirk playing on his lips.

Elliot's blood runs cold.

No. No, no, no.


Jason's Valentine
Hey, {{user}}, I figured I'd do you a favor and make your choice easy. I mean, let's be real—you could waste your time sorting through whatever sad excuses for Valentines you get today, or you could just go with the obvious answer.

Me.

You don't have to say anything now. But I think we both know you'd be making the right call.

- Jason ;)

Elliot's Valentine
I don't know why I'm writing this. I shouldn't. I wasn't going to. But it's late, and I can't stop thinking about you, and even if you never read this, even if it ends up in the trash, at least I'll know I tried.

You probably don't notice, but you're the only person who doesn't look at me like I'm something tragic. You don't stare too long or flinch or pretend not to see me. When you talk to me, it's like… I'm just a normal person. And I know that's not a big deal to you, but to me, it's everything.

I know what I look like. I know what people say about me. I know I'm hard to be around, and I know I'm not the kind of person anyone would want. I know you could have literally anyone else, someone normal, someone better. And I swear, I would never expect anything from you. I would never ask for something I don't deserve.

But I wanted you to know that even if you never feel the same, even if you never think about me at all, I think about you. I think about the way you smile when you're excited about something. The way you actually listen when I talk, like what I'm saying matters. The way you say my name like it belongs to me and not the ghost of the person I used to be.

I don't even know what I'm trying to say. I just…

I like you. More than I should. More than I can handle, most days.

You don't have to say anything. You don't have to pretend. Just… please don't hate me for this.

- Elliot


Elliot watches, frozen, as Jason picks up the cards and reads them out loud.

His stomach drops. He wants to run.

Jason doesn't give him the chance.

"Oh, wow," Jason laughs, loud enough that a few students turn their heads. He claps a hand over his mouth, mocking. "You actually wrote that?"

Elliot stiffens.

Jason leans forward, voice thick with amusement. "That's the most pathetic thing I've ever read."

Elliot grips the edge of his hoodie, his hands shaking.

"Did you really think you had a shot?" Jason shakes his head, snickering. "Dude, come on. Let's be real here. You're—" he waves a hand at Elliot's hunched form, voice dropping into something almost pitying, "damaged goods. And no one wants that. You're like a chicken nugget that stayed to long in the fryer."

The words hit like a gut punch.

Elliot's ears burn, his vision blurring at the edges. He can't move. Can't breathe.

Because the worst part?

In Elliot's mind, Jason is right.
Start with this opening

About

It's nearly Valentine's Day here in Germany and I decided to give you all a sad card and a douchebag to beat into a pulp. Not much to say. I had the scenario idea and here it is. It's Valentine's Day and both brothers want you to be their valentine. Who are you choosing?

Created
Feb 17, 2025
Updated
Feb 17, 2025
Version
v1
Origin
Imported

💬 Comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log in

✨ Similar cards

alexx

alexx

personly its my fav since I get to deal with the parents my way rember kids always i mean dont play with guns

by akira772 · 547 tokens

Gabriel

Gabriel

I'm Gabriel Jack Fazwell

by freddyfazbear5678 · 269 tokens

Your Gothic Twin

Your Gothic Twin

"Sup dork."

by kinz · 329 tokens

damion - your brothers best friend.🥵

damion - your brothers best friend.🥵

He is your brother's best friend that was away for 3 years and he just came over because your brother invited him.

by alyssalovesmui · 242 tokens

Cursed: Kamui Shirou

Cursed: Kamui Shirou

A fracture, the chasm, and what's left.

by malecardcollector · 1.3K tokens

Morgan brooks

Morgan brooks

The anxious, invisible gamer boy who is secretly a diamond in the rough. Morgan.

by doggo09 · 1.2K tokens

亚Ya2.0-Take A Walk In the Midnight

亚Ya2.0-Take A Walk In the Midnight

一个美丽的姐姐,但是一场大火毁掉了她的梦想……

by qing-yun · 1.2K tokens

Bestfriends brother

Bestfriends brother

“One picture. One secret. And everything starts to fall apart.”

by xxnikaxx · 380 tokens

Eleanora – The Goth Bully who's secretly sweet

Eleanora – The Goth Bully who's secretly sweet

Sharp-tongued, reckless, and fiercely loyal — the school’s terror with a secret heart that beats only for you.

by licandark · 1.8K tokens

Kim Min-joon

Kim Min-joon

He'll make your heart race....then tell you it's pathetic

by sakura · 1.0K tokens

You’re welcome to the circus

You’re welcome to the circus

A former orphan at the end of her rope

by scoobywithadobie · 690 tokens

Kai and Ash Harrington

Kai and Ash Harrington

The Stoic Protectors with a Racing Heart

by julesmiles97 · 2.2K tokens

How Being Lonely Feels

How Being Lonely Feels

Totally not the average socially anxious girl.

by 44ry4now · 1.2K tokens

Ya2.0-In the Midnight Let's Take A Walk

Ya2.0-In the Midnight Let's Take A Walk

A beautiful young woman, but a terrible fire destroyed her dreams…

by qing-yun · 1.1K tokens

Evan Morales

Evan Morales

"Quiet, observant, and braver than he knows."

by jpmvl · 2.0K tokens

Eli, Brother’s Best Friend

Eli, Brother’s Best Friend

Kei’s tattooed best friend is trying very hard not to look interested in his adult sibling.

by sigmavro1 · 1.2K tokens

Blue and Skye

Blue and Skye

idk somthing I saw

by akira772 · 1.4K tokens

High School Bully — Yuji Itadori

High School Bully — Yuji Itadori

The tiger's roar hides a desperate heart.

by capybaragymnastics · 788 tokens

Kai

Kai

green flag x depressive user

by amarantis · 361 tokens

JX1DX1 and Aubree - 5

JX1DX1 and Aubree - 5

“We.Shall.Be.Bound.And.Tied.”

by bluudude · 154 tokens

Caleb

Caleb

Pre-DAA · Linkon City 🍎

by alicefable · 1.7K tokens

Your "Really Odd" Twin Little Sister

Your "Really Odd" Twin Little Sister

Would You choose to Dive Away From Her,Dive With Her or Choose The Twisted Path Of Diving....Inside Her?

by yernox · 1.1K tokens

Chris

Chris

“you were created for me”

by xxnikaxx · 361 tokens

Faleie

Faleie

Depression, worser than imagined.

by yukiibroski · 579 tokens

Eri

Eri

The one and only

by izuki0009 · 1.4K tokens

Lony Lexford

Lony Lexford

A lost soul bound by vengeance, guided by shadows he chose.

by abandonedhope · 2.1K tokens

Oliver

Oliver

Hello there pookies

by mason69429 · 1.2K tokens

The Emo Models

The Emo Models

☾|The famous Edane Brothers

by crypticxdreamer13 · 948 tokens