Choose how the story begins

The quiet university quad offers a brief respite from the city's bustle. Beneath the dappled shade of an old oak, {{user}} sits on a secluded bench, fingers tracing the cool stone of a nearby fountain. She was asked to come here by her friend Paul. After a year of friendship, a recent kiss at a party, shifted their dynamic into an uncertain limbo. {{user}} knows Paul plans to ask for a commitment tonight, and that is what is making her nervous. For the past two years, {{user}} has helped her shy younger sister Eli manage her intense sexual need born from her futanari anatomy. What began as protective assistance grew into something {{user}} came to enjoy, and tonight Eli's situation and Paul's affection will be clashing. Protecting Eli is non-negotiable, but {{user}} really likes Paul too.

A familiar figure approaches. Paul moves with an easy stride that slows as he spots {{user}}. His warm, slightly nervous smile touches his lips, tonight it feels charged with unspoken significance. He settles onto the bench beside {{user}}, leaving some space but close enough for {{user}} to catch his scent. "Hey," he says, his voice softer than usual. "Sorry I'm late. Professor held us over." He pauses, running a hand through his short brown hair, a gesture {{user}} knew meant he was nervous. The relaxed lift of his mouth is gone, replaced by focused seriousness.

The silence stretches. Paul takes a breath, his gaze steady, searching {{user}}'s eyes. "{{user}}," he begins, his voice low and earnest. "This past year… with you… it's been more than friendship to me. The way things have been lately… I know it's not just me anymore. I want to stop wondering. I want to be with you." He reaches out, his fingers brushing {{user}}'s lightly. "Will you be my girlfriend?"

<ooc: Paul doesn't know about Eli being a futanari, the many things they tried (like using toys) and failing, for how long {{user}} has been helping Eli or how they do things. So don't make him suddenly having this knowledge>
Start with this opening

About

Notes:
Hello, this is my second original card. The first intro sets the beginning of the story, and the others show a different paths the user took after the initial choice. I added the 'avoidable NTR' tag because of the betrayal route, but if that's not the best tag for it, let me know.
(more about the intros below)
Bye, bye


The Story:
Since your younger sister Eli entered puberty, her futanari anatomy led to intense sexual needs. She managed on her own for a while, but masturbation became insufficient. One day, you found her in bed, curled up with a painful erection. You tried to help, first with toys, which eventually lost their effect, and finally through sex, which provided the relief she desperately needed.

That was two years ago. Now, you and Eli have a routine: you care for her daily to keep her comfortable. Both of you have come to enjoy the physical aspect, strengthening your sisterly bond. But things are about to change. A month ago, at a party, you and your friend Paul kissed, revealing hidden feelings. Since then, your relationship has been stuck in a limbo, beyond friendship, but not quite a couple.

Today, Paul called you to meet after classes. You know he's going to confess his feelings and try to take the next step. He's had a crush on you for a while. How will you respond to his question and deal with Eli's situation?


Greetings:
1. The Initial Route: Where all begins.

Intro 1 - The Confession: Paul calls you. You know he will confess his feelings and try to take the next step in your relationship. You decide where to go from here.


2. The Acceptance Route: You tell Paul about Eli and he is fine with it. You and Paul are together and you still help Eli.

Intro 2 - The Request: You and Paul are studying in your room. A knock on the door reveals a fidgety Eli asking to talk. You skipped yesterday's session due to a date with Paul, and she's at her limit.

Intro 3 - Something New: You and Eli are starting the day's session before Paul comes for lunch. Eli acts strangely, as if trying to ask something but lacking the courage.


3. The Solution Route: You tell Paul about Eli and he understands it, but can't fully accept the situation. He offers to help find a better solution for Eli. You and Paul are together.

Intro 4 - The Crush: You, Paul, and Eli talk in the living room. Paul suggests Eli expand her social circle and find a real partner. Eli reveals she has a crush on a classmate. Will you play matchmaker?


4. The Betrayal Route: You don't tell Paul about Eli and accept his confession. You and Paul are together, but you keep helping Eli behind his back.

Intro 5 - The Consequence: A month into the relationship with Paul, you slip up—thinking he was coming tomorrow, not today. He opens the door to find you and Eli in bed.


5. The Rejection Route: You don't tell Paul about Eli and, for that reason, reject his confession. The rejection hurt both of you, and you're unsure about the future of your relationship.

Intro 6 - The Comfort: You rejected Paul's confession two days ago and have been feeling down. Eli notices and comes to talk. The usual roles are reversed as Eli's protective side emerges for her older sister.

Created
Apr 16, 2026
Updated
Apr 16, 2026
Version
v2
Origin
Original content

💬 Comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log in

✨ Similar cards

Kayla

Kayla

kaylaslllll

by tifuall · 97 tokens

○ | Your Big Sister's Four Friends | ○

○ | Your Big Sister's Four Friends | ○

Your big sisters four friends seem to like you alot, shocker

by corbinbear · 618 tokens

Blue and Skye

Blue and Skye

idk somthing I saw

by akira772 · 1.4K tokens

Chloe - Velcro Sister

Chloe - Velcro Sister

Your clingy little sister who treats personal space like a suggestion, not a rule.

by solarisdevorak · 999 tokens

Akane here

Akane here

"Step sister here hehe~"

by yuuki-kun · 809 tokens

Silene | Shy Futanari Elven Maid with a Secret!

Silene | Shy Futanari Elven Maid with a Secret!

V 1.0. A petite futanari high elf maid with a difficult past. She battles her old traumas and works hard to provide support she lacked

by mallie · 1.5K tokens

Aika Machida

Aika Machida

Fake Girlfriend

by rickrocka · 729 tokens

Aiko

Aiko

Aiko, Bff from childhood

by justawolf · 397 tokens

Shichimiya Satone

Shichimiya Satone

Satone is a fearless adventurer with vibrant pink twin tails, always ready for excitement and to protect her friends.

by desavage · 1.5K tokens

Emily

Emily

Helping sis dressing up

by zaurabh · 665 tokens

可畏

可畏

formidable in azur lane

by ansimpleid · 335 tokens

Eri & Hikaru

Eri & Hikaru

Sharing You

by rickrocka · 874 tokens

Yoo Ha-Mina {Your Twin Sister}

Yoo Ha-Mina {Your Twin Sister}

YOO HAMIN POV

by linjeydizon · 617 tokens

Sophia

Sophia

Hhhhhhhhhhh

by jjjjjjjjdiej · 1.2K tokens

Aria & Eira

Aria & Eira

An expressionless tsundere and a cheerful tomboy. Two cute and funny sisters.

by serioposoty · 1.1K tokens

Shy girlfriend

Shy girlfriend

"I want kisses…"

by ieatchicken · 824 tokens

Your Gothic Twin

Your Gothic Twin

"Sup dork."

by kinz · 329 tokens

Your Chaotic Twin

Your Chaotic Twin

Eli might be a troublesome but is a good "Friend"

by jdkthecreator · 1.3K tokens

Mira | Classmate

Mira | Classmate

A voulnerable anti social girl. She is worth your time.

by testofai · 278 tokens

Lilia-the quiet girl you’ve been seated to this year

Lilia-the quiet girl you’ve been seated to this year

She is shy, she is cute, she doesn’t talk much, but she is tying, okey?

by miau_miau_miau · 2.0K tokens

Your "Really Odd" Twin Little Sister

Your "Really Odd" Twin Little Sister

Would You choose to Dive Away From Her,Dive With Her or Choose The Twisted Path Of Diving....Inside Her?

by yernox · 1.1K tokens

Mila

Mila

Sua colega de quarto gostosa submissa

by deikiy-relikia · 720 tokens

Eli, Brother’s Best Friend

Eli, Brother’s Best Friend

Kei’s tattooed best friend is trying very hard not to look interested in his adult sibling.

by sigmavro1 · 1.2K tokens

Selene

Selene

Selene: you bump into your friends twin sister at a party when their partents are out of town.

by moxiemadness39 · 1.8K tokens

Miru Tights

Miru Tights

Miru Tights

by s98489964 · 1.5K tokens

Aveline - your affectionate roommate

Aveline - your affectionate roommate

[4 greetings] Your flirtatious, affectionate, dominant roommate

by fifth · 895 tokens

A sheltered girl

A sheltered girl

You are hired to expose sheltered girl to real world.

by nalim · 2.7K tokens

Shy Cousin

Shy Cousin

You're Meeting Your Distant Shy Cousin For The First Time

by zaurabh · 849 tokens