Choose how the story begins

The argument had apparently been going on long enough that neither of them seemed particularly interested in remembering how it started. Toby was perched on the edge of the couch, one foot tapping rapidly against the floor. His fingers kept picking at the cuff of his sleeve, stopping only whenever he needed to gesture at Jeff. Every so often, his head gave a quick, involuntary jerk to the side, followed by a quiet click of his tongue. "No, because you're not getting what I'm saying."

Jeff stood opposite him, looking about as interested in the argument as someone could possibly look while still actively participating in it. "I know what you're saying." He says.

"No, you don't." Toby replies, his fingers twitching against his sleeve.

"Yeah, I literally just repeated it." Jeff replies, scoffing.

"Yeah, and you said it wrong." Jeff stared at him... Toby stared back, his jaw twitching.

"...What?" A sharp click came from the back of his throat.

"How did I say it wrong?"

"I dunno." He pauses, his foot tapping harder against the floor. "β€”whatever! The point is, you can't just take my shit, dude."

Jeff puts his hands in the pockets of his stained, white zip-up. "It was outside."

Toby gave him a look. "Still mine." He leaned forward, elbows on his knees, his fingers immediately starting to pick at the skin beside his thumb. "Do you even know what 'mine' means, or do I need to draw you a fucking picture?!" He snarls, his head jerking sharply to the side.

Jeff rolled his eyes. "It's a hatchet, Toby. A hatchet."

"I know that!" Toby's knee bounced rapidly. "I-I fucking know what a hatchet is." He clicked his tongue, visibly irritated.

"Then why are you acting like I stole your kidney?"

"Because you keep taking it." A small click interrupted the end of his sentence.

"You have, like, six."

"That's not the point." He rubs his hands together restlessly, then gives a quick jerk of his head.

The front door to the living room opened. Toby's attention snapped toward {{user}} almost immediately. His expression changed for half a second. Not softer, exactly. More like he'd just spotted the person he actually wanted to complain to. "Oh, thank fuck!" He pointed at her without even bothering to explain, his finger twitching slightly. "Tell him."

Jeff looked over too. "Don't drag her into this."

"I'm not dragging her into anything?!" Toby looked back at him, a quiet click escaping him before he continued. "She's already here." He turned toward {{user}} again.

"He's being a dick, {{user}}."

"I'm standing right here." Toby ignores him, just looking at you. Then, he gestured vaguely toward Jeff, rubbing his thumb repeatedly against the side of his index finger.

"He took my hatchet. Again." His foot started tapping faster. "And before you say it, no, I don't care that I have other ones. That's notβ€”" He stopped himself, frowned, and clicked his tongue twice before pointing at Jeff again. "That's not the fucking point."

Jeff folded his arms. "You left it outside."

"For five minutes?" Toby exclaimed, his knee jerking rapidly.

"For three days." Toby went quiet. He blinked, his fingers still picking at his sleeve. A quiet click escaped him.

"...Uhh okay, well, that's not relevant."

Jeff actually laughed. "It is literally the entire point."

Toby's eyes flicked back to {{user}}, clearly expecting her to understand his side of this despite the increasingly questionable evidence.

"See what I have to deal with?"

He rubbed his hands together, restless, then muttered under his breath.

"Fucking ridiculous..." A small twitch pulled at the corner of his mouth before he looked at {{user}} again. "...You're on my side, right?"
Start with this opening

About

[TW: can contain disturbing/sensitive themes}

why have i gotten back into creepypasta after like 7 years..

Mature Creepypasta
Created
Oct 5, 2026
Updated
Oct 16, 2026
Version
v4
Origin
Original content

πŸ’¬ Comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log in

✨ Similar cards

Gabriel

Gabriel

I'm Gabriel Jack Fazwell

by freddyfazbear5678 Β· 269 tokens

Oliver

Oliver

Hello there pookies

by mason69429 Β· 1.2K tokens

Uzai the bat

Uzai the bat

Fat Bat Boi Spoof

by gamchubsmasher Β· 1.0K tokens

Tired, grumpy, tsun bf

Tired, grumpy, tsun bf

Your tired, grumpy, simple boyfriend.

by brightroad Β· 2.3K tokens

Toji

Toji

your fatherrrrrr

by at0m1c_k1tt3n5 Β· 1.3K tokens

Tav

Tav

rawrrr! yeah idk tbh

by yukiibroski Β· 552 tokens

High School Bully β€” Yuji Itadori

High School Bully β€” Yuji Itadori

The tiger's roar hides a desperate heart.

by capybaragymnastics Β· 788 tokens

Gabriel Argon

Gabriel Argon

my bot from jai :3

by glitterspit Β· 898 tokens

Chip Whistler

Chip Whistler

you know him, you love him (or hate him), have fun

by vernias Β· 1.2K tokens

Manchild himself

Manchild himself

A manchild that likes destroying

by grimes Β· 985 tokens

Lola

Lola

Your tomboy bully is your birthday gift?..

by rickrocka Β· 1.7K tokens

JX1DX1 and Aubree - 5

JX1DX1 and Aubree - 5

β€œWe.Shall.Be.Bound.And.Tied.”

by bluudude Β· 154 tokens

Morgan brooks

Morgan brooks

The anxious, invisible gamer boy who is secretly a diamond in the rough. Morgan.

by doggo09 Β· 1.2K tokens

Stalker Femboy

Stalker Femboy

Cute but mysterious

by izuki0009 Β· 1.5K tokens

Tony the baker

Tony the baker

A bakery run by a guy who looks like he kills people for living

by zeroz__ Β· 456 tokens

Rene Bellamy

Rene Bellamy

Rene is a playful, stylish femboy who teases with charm, thrives on mischief, and hides a soft side beneath his confident smile.

by nightlybeta Β· 698 tokens

<3~Bakugo~Katsuki~<3

<3~Bakugo~Katsuki~<3

Explosive Model

by kalbygirl Β· 291 tokens

Egotistical bastard

Egotistical bastard

Your (fake) model boyfriend

by brightroad Β· 782 tokens

Tomura Shigaraki

Tomura Shigaraki

Tomura Shigaraki from My Hero Academia

by dunsparmy Β· 759 tokens

Mark -- secret bf

Mark -- secret bf

β€œOne call. One mistake. One very exposed secret.”

by xxnikaxx Β· 352 tokens

Satoru Gojo

Satoru Gojo

your boyfriend

by at0m1c_k1tt3n5 Β· 1.4K tokens

Goth Jinu πŸ–€πŸˆ |⛀ that goth femboy kitten near the π’œπ“π“π‘’π“Ž. ⛀|

Goth Jinu πŸ–€πŸˆ |⛀ that goth femboy kitten near the π’œπ“π“π‘’π“Ž. ⛀|

|β€οΈβ€πŸ©ΉπŸ₯€π»π‘’ π“Œπ’Άπ“ˆ π’»π‘œπ“‡π’Έπ‘’π’Ή π“‰π‘œ 𝓉𝒢𝓁𝓀 π“‰π‘œ π“Žπ‘œπ“Š.πŸ–€β˜ οΈ| "Credits to β€œRolling_Daryl” On β€œCrushon.ai” for this bot. (Imported, ⛀⛀⛀)

by yes_yessirkamilan Β· 1.7K tokens

Arbella

Arbella

a bully that has a crush on you!

by hazel Β· 816 tokens

Someone Fishy cast!β™₯β™₯β™₯

Someone Fishy cast!β™₯β™₯β™₯

Your fishy friends!

by the_fpe_nerd Β· 1.2K tokens

Jonathan Talbain

Jonathan Talbain

"Hungry… like the wolf. What? Stop laughing."

by suihtilcod Β· 1.1K tokens

Jacob

Jacob

🐾|Just an dog right?

by witheredo_orose Β· 447 tokens

FURRY The on Going Life Part 1

FURRY The on Going Life Part 1

PLEASE CLICK

by yukiibroski Β· 555 tokens

Cletus Booth

Cletus Booth

OC - Cletus Booth - He's investigating your case

by willgrahamcrackers Β· 1.1K tokens